Why Do Men Having a Midlife Crisis Blame Their Marriage for Their Unhappiness?

By: Leslie Cane: I wish I could say that midlife crises were rare occurrences, but they aren’t. Studies show that as many as 20% of adults will have this sort of crisis in their lives. It would be bad enough if the crisis only affected the person having it, but this isn’t the case. The crisis will often affect spouses, children, and marriages. In short, it may damage all of the people around the person having it.

Not surprisingly, many wives with husbands going through a crisis feel unfairly singled out because the husband will begin to blame the marriage or the wife for all of the unhappiness that he may be experiencing.

Suddenly, he’s not sure if he wants to be married anymore because he thinks that the relationship no longer serves him. Needless to say, this can be incredibly confusing to a wife who has supported and loved this man for many years of their lives.

She might say, “My husband is very obviously having a midlife crisis. He is suddenly tired of many of his friends, family, and me. He has decided that he needs to reevaluate every area of his life. He just left a job and a career that he’s had for many years – even if that means taking a substantial pay cut. He’s dropped many close friends that he has known since childhood. And now he is telling me that he isn’t sure that he wants to be married to me anymore. “

“This really upsets and angers me because I know that I’m not really the problem. He’s ignoring the health scares he’s had over the year which probably made him think about his mortality. He refuses to think about the fact that he changed careers because he was scared he would be fired. In other words, he’s had many issues and problems over the last year that could obviously be the source of his unhappiness. But he’s choosing to blame his relationships (and me) instead. Why do men do this? Why is our marriage being solely blamed for his crippling unhappiness? It’s so unfair.”

I agree with you that it’s not only unfair, but it’s also not at all accurate in most cases. I’ll offer some suggestions on how to deal with this, but first, I want to list some reasons that he may be blaming your marriage, as follows:

You’re the Easiest Target: Everyone who is a parent knows that when a child is having a meltdown or a teenager is deeply unhappy, mom or dad is going to get the brunt of it. The parents are going to be portrayed as “mean” or “clueless” because they are the person who is closest to the struggling child, and they are the ones who are going to be the most hurt by the accusations. The parent is also the person most likely to give the child the desired response.

The same is true of a spouse having a midlife crisis. Frankly, a midlife crisis is painful, even if the person having it doesn’t fully realize they are in pain. So they’ll often lash out at the person who they know will be their easiest target and who will give them the most dramatic response – you. 

The plus side to this is that his choosing you for his most painful actions means he’s subconsciously aware that you’re the one he’s closest to in his life. That means something. 

He May Suddenly Feel That A Long-Term Reliance on The Same Relationship Takes His Autonomy and Power Away: Sometimes men having a midlife crisis fear being “whipped” or they worry that they’ve been harmed in some way by staying in the relationship for so long. Is there something they’ve missed out on by being married? Could they become a better version of themselves if they decided to go it alone? 

For whatever reason, they’ve decided that they can improve their lives by evaluating and then changing what no longer works for them. And they can sometimes mistakenly suspect that their marriage has been one of these things all along.

They May Convince Themselves that They’ve Outgrown the Relationship, Have Become Bored With It, Or Deserve Better: I am in no way saying that any of these things are true. But husbands who are tempted to discard their wives or their marriages due to midlife crisis will often convince themselves that the problem is totally with the marriage – it’s grown stale, the spark is gone, or it no longer serves either spouse.

Much of the time, he can’t evaluate his relationships properly. He lacks objectivity because of the crisis itself. Therefore, his destructive thoughts continue to cycle and strengthen his resolve. 

How to Handle This: I completely understand why a wife would want to tell her husband that he’s not himself and is acting irrationally. Because frankly, he often is. 

However, it helps for you to counter his irrationality with your own rational thinking. He isn’t likely to listen to reason right now, because he is being influenced by the uncertainty in his life more than anything else. 

If you tell him he’s wrong, or acting irrationally, or even having a midlife crisis, he will use this as confirmation of his negative feelings toward you and the marriage. The strategy of trying to talk some sense into him often backfires.

Instead, try your best to remain calm and try to see him as someone who is injured and therefore blowing up his life. You can’t necessarily stop him from the things that he is doing, but you can tell him that you still care about him and will be there to listen and support him anytime he wishes. 

Try to move slowly and not make rash decisions because frankly, sometimes in time, the midlife crisis will burn itself out, and he will realize that he’s wrong and has been acting irrationally, and you won’t have to do or say anything. 

And because you’ve portrayed yourself as someone who tried to be supportive, you’ll be in a much better position than the wife who told him he was acting like a stupid old fool.

I know wives are reading this who worry that he’ll never grow out of the midlife crisis. And I can’t tell you that’s impossible. But many men do ease out of this phase eventually, and you don’t want to make an enemy of him in the meantime. 

Before my own husband came out of his thinking, I panicked and did things that only made the situation worse.  Therefore, I had a much bigger mess to clean up.  I eventually began to understand how to approach things calmly instead of without panic. And I learned how to approach my husband as a partner rather than an adversary.  This changed everything and allowed us to eventually reconcile.  You can read that whole story at https://isavedmymarriage.com

Fixing A Loveless Marriage: Is It Possible? How Can You Do It?

By: Leslie Cane: Many people wonder about loveless, broken marriages. They want to know to survive them, how to be happy in them, or how to live in harmony within one, especially for the sake of children. Very interestingly, there aren’t quite as many requests for advice on how to fix them. It seems that couples living in a loveless marriage don’t think that it can ever change or really improve.

This is frustrating because I’ve seen countless so-called “loveless” or “broken” marriages turn around quite dramatically. And living in a home filled with love and affection truly is, at least in my opinion, the gold standard for all involved. So, in the following article, I’m going to tell you how I think it’s possible to fix or repair a loveless marriage.

The First Step In Repairing A Broken Marriage Is Not Allowing Definitions To Limit Your Beliefs: Here’s a common denominator that I often find in this situation. People’s perceptions and definitions can very much affect the outcome. And once you start referring to your marriage as “loveless,” you truly do limit your emotions, your perceptions, your expectations, and possibly the health of your marriage.

I certainly don’t doubt that your marriage is struggling, could well be non fulfilling, and could feel quite devoid of love. Many people in this situation say that they’re only going through the motions, living like roommates – never even acknowledging each other, or often only communicate in a negative way. I understand that it’s hard not to place labels on a situation like this. But please try to keep an open mind moving forward. This can make all the difference.

Determining Why Your Marriage No Longer Feels Loving: The next step would be pinpointing why you’re experiencing your marriage as you are. Why does it feel “loveless” to you? What is turning you (or your spouse) off the most? And, how long has it been this way? Because one thing that I almost always find is that very few marriages have been “loveless” from the very beginning.

No, typically something somewhere along the line changed. And sometimes, people will claim that it’s their spouse who has changed. I often hear comments like: “My husband has completely changed. He’s not the man I married. He’s lazy and sarcastic and I don’t even like him anymore, much less love him.” From husbands I hear things like: “My wife used to be so caring and so much fun. She used to listen to me and laugh with me. But now, she just looks at me as though I’ve disappointed her. She looks right through me and then nags.”

These perceptions can cloud and choke out the good things within your marriage and feed on themselves. And, when the perceptions change, unfortunately priorities and attention changes also. The final change is the feelings.

So, maybe you did go out and do fun things together regularly in the beginning of your marriage, but you doubt very much that this is possible now. Or, your spouse used to go out of their way to show and tell you how much they loved and appreciated you, but they rarely give you a second glance lately.

Why “Neglected” is a Better Description for a Broken Marriage: All of these changes are what contribute to your changing feelings and the way that you see and define your marriage. I often tell people that I think “neglected” is a better adjective for this kind of marriage than “loveless.”

And it’s not always the marriage that the spouses neglect. Yes, they neglect each other. But, they often neglect themselves also. Their happiness level goes way down and they sort of shut down and begin stumbling through every day and going through the motions without even thinking.

Shaking Up A Loveless Marriage To Repair The Damage And Get The Loving Feelings Back: If you continue on the way that you are, it’s likely a fair assumption that the way you feel won’t change either. And very often, when a marriage has become “loveless,” one of the reasons for this is that you’ve gotten into destructive habits. You must break these. And, that can be difficult when you’ve established negative marital norms that at least feel predictable.

But someone has to be that brave person who is going to stand up and shake things up a bit. Yes, this can make you feel exposed and vulnerable. But it’s sometimes worth it in the end. Ask your spouse on a date. Compliment them. Ask them open ended questions and really listen. Pinpoint what bothers you the most and have the courage to change it in a kind and loving way.

I know that some people think I’m nuts when I offer these suggestions. But I’ve seen marriages long left for dead produce people who are giggling like teenagers after pouring very deliberate attention onto their spouse and their marriage again. If your spouse isn’t giving you what you need to feel loved and loving, then ask yourself if you’re doing the same for them and then do it if you’re not.

All of us want the same things. We want to feel adored, understood and desired. If you make your spouse feel this way, they will likely eventually return the effort and you may well find yourself in a brand new marriage.

It’s very much my opinion and experience that it’s much easier to “fix” a seemingly loveless marriage than it is to start over when you may have already found your soulmate but no longer recognize or appreciate them due to your own perceptions and labels.

It was my husband, not me, who felt that our marriage was “loveless,” so he threatened to end it. (And I wasn’t always thrilled with it either.) I knew that it wasn’t over for me and I refused to give up. But, for a long time what I did was not working.  Thankfully, I realized my mistake and changed course. This shift changed my marriage. You can read that story on my blog at https://isavedmymarriage.com/.

What it Really Means When a Husband Says He’s “Trying” To Love His Wife

By: Leslie Cane: The other day, I received an email from a friend who wrote: “my husband told me that he’s not in love with me anymore.  He didn’t say it in a mean or spiteful way.  He was just being honest.  He said that he’s ‘trying’ to hang in there and regain the spark, but I just don’t know what to do about this. How am I suppose to process the fact that my husband doesn’t love me anymore and has to ‘try’ to stay with me?  I feel like something that is undesirable and tarnished, like an out of date tool that he no longer has any use for, but which he’s just going to keep around because he feels that he should or because he has some sentimental value or loyalty (but no love) toward it.”

Putting The Husband’s “Trying To Love” His Wife In Perspective:  First off, I cautioned the wife not to focus on the semantics too much.  Sometimes, we obsess over the words and phrasing that someone uses without realizing that that person probably didn’t give the words much thought when they said them.

These were the words that came out at the time, but that doesn’t mean that you need to analyze every syllable or stake your marriage on his choice of words.

It’s important to use this for what it is – a wake up call and a second chance.  So many wives have husbands who have proclaimed that they no longer love them and / or have filed divorce papers.  These wives were blindsided and have less of a chance to change things before a divorce is final.

So, as much as it may feel like you’re in an awful situation right now, know that it could be worse.  By being honest with you, your husband has shown that he’s still communicating and is still open to the idea that the love can be restored.

What No Longer Loving You Probably Really Means:  Men are not good at evaluating and then communicating their feelings.  Often they think they are “no longer in love with you,” when in fact they’re no longer enamored with their life or with how the relationship is going right now.  They’re remembering what was and contrasting that with what currently is and they’re feeling disappointed and let down.

Yes, this isn’t altogether fair.  Day to day stressors are realities of life and it’s likely that both of you are juggling twice as much as you did when you were falling in love.  And men very often know this intellectually, but they are still let down emotionally.

So as hard as it is, don’t take this business personally.  Because I’d be willing to bet that if you could alleviate some of the stress, take the time to find the environment conducive to bonding and sharing, and focus on what brings you together rather than what drives you apart, things would begin to look (and feel) a whole lot different.

Reality Today Compared To What It Used To Be: Hopefully, I’ve given you something to think about. It may be the bond that’s been lost rather than the love that has been lost. Husbands will often perceive it this way, but they are very often wrong.  What has really happened is that the bond and intimacy have changed, not the love.

So, how can you use this knowledge to your advantage? Well, you can start by calming down and realizing that you just need to change up the perception and the bond.  This is usually a gradual process that can’t be rushed.  But, with repetitive and careful effort, eventually you will see things begin to change.

Think back to what really drove your relationship when you first fell in love.  Many people will mention “sex” when I being up this consideration.  But, I would argue that it was not so much sex as the excitement and the intimacy that you felt. You felt desired, loved, understood, valued, and unique.

The key word here, is, believe it or not, unique.  People in love feel like they’ve finally found the other part to their whole.  They feel that they’ve finally found the person that completes them – the role that no one else could fill.  But, this is often the result of the time and attention that you devote to them.  You value their experiences, their perceptions, and their journey through life and this makes them feel uniquely special

What would happen if you tried this approach again? Honestly, what if you began to prioritize the way that you did when you were dating? It certainly couldn’t hurt, right?

Now, you can’t come on too strong or appear in genuine.  You must pace yourself so that this new tactic appears to be spontaneous.  You can’t force it, but you can allow it to happen in the way that you have set it up.

I know that things seem not so great right now, but think about the advantage you have.  You know how and why this guy falls in love.  You know his history and what he values. This is likely a larger advantage than you think.

I was devastated when my husband told me that he was no longer in love with me. For a long time, fear caused me to draw on my own fears and insecurities Thankfully, I realized this didn’t serve me (or my marriage) and changed course. Eventually, I was able to not only restore my husband’s love (which I’m not sure ever really left,) but to save our marriage. You can read more on my blog at https://isavedmymarriage.com/.

I’m Not Sure If My Husband Ever Really Loved Me And He Doesn’t Love Me Now

by: Leslie Cane: Many of the wives who read my articles feel sure that their husbands don’t love them. Occasionally, I hear from someone who tells me that their husband has never loved them. An example is the wife who was beside herself and very upset about the way that her husband has been treating her. He’d been shutting her out, spending less time at home, and was basically just ignoring her as though she didn’t exist.

One day she got so frustrated at this that she snapped: “This isn’t how you treat someone you love.” This did not sit well with the husband who snapped back: “I don’t love you. I’m not sure if I ever have loved you.” Needless to say, the silence and the tension was thick in the room after this. And, since then, the two had just been completely avoiding each other. The wife was furious that he would speak to her in this way. But, deep down, she was also very hurt because the suspected that there was a lot of truth behind that outburst.

The points she made went something like this: “I don’t think we would even be married if I hadn’t become pregnant with our daughter. When I got pregnant, we had just broken up. He was the one who broke it off. And at that point, I think he was relieved that the relationship was over. But of course, once I got pregnant, everything changed. I hoped that our daughter would bring us closer together, and for a while, she did. Eventually though, my husband seemed more and more unhappy and it became obvious that he resented the situation. Sure, we’ve had some good times and I wouldn’t trade my daughter for anything in the world. There are days when he’s sweet to both of us and this does make me feel loved. But there are also days when I think he just wants to pack his bags and leave us. I don’t know what to do. I want a stable home for my daughter, but don’t I deserve someone who really loves me?”

Of course she deserved to feel loved. Everyone does. However, I have to say that claims made in anger aren’t always true. It’s quite possible that the husband was only trying to get a reaction and knew the precise words which were going to cut the deepest. This couple had been together for a year and a half before the wife became pregnant. Clearly, there was something other than their daughter that was drawing them together over that relatively long period of time. I think this was a situation which could potentially be worked out which I will discuss below.

Do Not Allow For Your Husband’s Hurtful Claim That He Doesn’t Love You Now (And Has Never Loved You) To Derail You From Getting What You Really Want: Feeling loved is an inherent desire that we all share. Everyone who has invested time and emotion into a relationship very much want the pay off of knowing that all of the feelings are mutual. No one wants to feel as though they are the only person experiencing love in the relationship. Everyone wants to feel desired and special.

With that said though, both people in the relationship know this. So, pulling the rug out from under someone is a surefire way to get the hurtful response that you are looking for. There’s no doubt in my mind that this husband knew full well that claiming not to love this wife was going to be the most hurtful (and hard hitting) thing which he could possibly say to her.

And, yes, it got the desired result. After those words were spoken, she retreated and stopped nagging him to spend more time with her and to treat her better. And this is likely precisely what he wanted anyway.

However, after listening to this couple’s history, I just did not buy that this man had never loved this woman. He had spent much of their time together working quite hard to raise the funds to build a home for them. He made sure to buy into a neighborhood with the best schools for their daughter. He regularly surprised the wife with books because he knew that reading was one thing she missed as a busy parent to a toddler. Some of the things he did showed that he loved, understood, and valued his wife very much.

But, it was also very clear that he felt pressured and afraid with all of the new responsibility on his shoulders. These negative feelings may have been at least in part behind him recently lashing out at her. And, although these behaviors were hurtful (and frankly unacceptable,) I honestly didn’t feel that the whole truth was behind them.

Try to Approach it From a Place of Solutions Rather than Resentment and Pain: So, where does the wife go from here? Looking at it from the surface, this is a tough situation. It hurts to hear those kinds of statements. But, I felt very strongly that the wife had to step back and ask herself what she really wanted the most. It seemed relatively clear to me that she wanted to be part of a loving and stable family. Her daughter was a wonderful reality. She was here in the present time. Whatever happened in the past needed to stay there.

Right now, the most important thing was for them to raise their family in a loving environment that fulfilled them both. They were relatively young and had all kinds of time to learn new behaviors that weren’t based on pushing each other’s emotional buttons.

A Positive Way to Address it: I felt strongly that the wife should try to put the hurtful words behind her and address this with her husband. The things he said were hurtful and needed to stop. Besides that, no one had spoke of what he had said for days. It needed to be addressed. I suggested that the wife approach her husband when she could be calm and know that she wasn’t going to engage with them.

Then, I suggested that she say something like: “Your saying that you don’t love me now and never loved me really hurt me. It wasn’t a fair thing for you to say, but I suspect that you don’t really mean it. I don’t want for either of us to fall into these patterns. We both grew up in volatile homes and I don’t want this for our daughter. I know that the way we got married and started our family wasn’t planned. But we are here now and we have to move forward in a positive way. I love you and I want to work with you to lighten both of our loads so that we aren’t snapping at each other because of all the pressure we are under. Will you work with me to create the loving family that we both want and deserve? Let’s stop hurting each other. We’re better than that.”

Now, the husband may not fall into the wife’s arms and spew apologies like she was hoping for, but dealing with this in a loving and honest way was going to begin to break those destructive habits and patterns that had formed. And, if the two of them were able to alleviate some of the tension and stress, I suspected that those hurtful phrases about not loving the wife were going to hopefully stop.

It was my husband, not me, who took to saying hurtful things (like he didn’t love me) when we hit rough spots. Unfortunately, in response, I drew on negative emotions rather than positive ones. This seriously backfired. I had to change course to save my marriage, which was in serious jeopardy due to a separation caused by all the negativity.  You can read more at https://isavedmymarriage.com.

What Questions To Ask Your Husband If He Wants To Separate

By: Leslie Cane: Needless to say, wives of husbands who want to separate typically have a lot of questions that they want answered. But, they intuitively realize that this is a delicate situation and they aren’t quite sure which questions to ask and how to ask them.

I often hear comments like “Should I ask him if he wants to separate because there is someone else? Should I ask him if she still loves me? Should I ask him if we’re ultimately going to get a divorce? Should I ask him why he’s doing this to us?” I will try to address these concerns in the following article.

When Questioning Your Husband About His Wish For A Separation, Try To Focus On What Is Right In Front Of You Rather Than On The Long Term: Of course, the most pressing question for many wives in this situation is “will this eventually lead to us getting a divorce?” But, asking this might only intensify the issue even though it’s a legitimate question.

In my experience, the best result will often come if you limit yourself to the immediate future rather than demanding answers about the faraway outcome which he may not envision yet anyway. What good is it to keep pressing for an answer about where the separation is going to lead and then rush him into an answer that might be the one that you don’t want?

Try to Avoid Vague Questions You Know He Likely Won’t Answer: Another sticky situation question focuses on the why. Many of us want to know why. We think that if he can just get us an answer, we can begin to whittle away at his thought process and perhaps have a shot at changing his mind. However, sometimes this tactic can backfire because the husband becomes frustrated at the litany of questions and eventually wants to distance himself even more just to avoid all of the rapid fire grilling.

Focus On Short Term Questions that He and Will Answer: Sometimes, it is better to set things up to resolve as best as you can in the short term and let the rest work itself out.

Some things that you may want to clarify is how he envisions things working while you are separated. Does he plan to check in? Will you be communicating regularly? Can the two of you work together to set some ground rules or to make some improvements?

What You Might Want To Ask If You Sense He Isn’t Sure About The Separation: Some women want to question their husbands because they get the sense that he’s not 100 percent sure about or committed to actually separating.

Sometimes, they suspect that all of this separation talk is just his way to try to get their attention (and sometimes, they are right about this.) In this case, although it’s tempting to want to say, “Why are you doing this?,” you are better off asking opened ended but non accusatory questions that make him think that you really are on his side and want him to be happy.

A good example of this would be something like, “If you could have this situation work out any way that you wanted for it to, what would you want to happen? What is it that would make you more happy and content than you are right now? Is there anything that I can do to make this happen?”

Do you see the difference? You aren’t taking an accusatory tone and you aren’t giving him the impression that you are only interested in changing his mind. Instead, you are offering to listen to what he has to say and letting him know that you really do care what is making him unhappy and want to help him fix it. This will usually get you a lot further because he will realize that you are on his side and are an ally.

If Your Husband Is Going To Go Ahead With The Separation No Matter What You Ask Or Say: Sometimes, no matter which questions you ask, your husband is going to feel that he just needs or wants the separation. And I know from experience that this is a scary place to be. It can be heartbreaking to let him go ahead when you don’t know what tomorrow brings.

But sometimes, this is the right call. Sometimes, it is best to spin this in a positive way and feign confidence that you know you are meant to be together and that it will work out. In the meantime, it helps to paint yourself in the best light as is possible. He may change his mind and the separation won’t happen. But, if not, you want him to remember that you are still his partner,you still love him, and are still vibrant and self respecting enough to use this time on yourself and to your own advantage.

It was my husband, not me, who wanted the separation. I knew that it wasn’t over for me but I drew on negative emotions and this seriously backfired. Thankfully, I changed course and eventually saved our marriage. You can read a that story on my blog at https://isavedmymarriage.com/

 

Tips For When Your Husband Is Thinking About A Divorce

by: Leslie Cane:  It can be an awful feeling when you know your husband is thinking about a divorce, and it feels like there isn’t much you can do about it.

A wife in this situation might say: “My husband admitted to me last night that he’s been thinking about a divorce a lot lately. This doesn’t completely surprise me. We’ve been having some problems for a while. But they are not problems that I would think should mean the end of a marriage. The economy has caused a lot of issues and stress for us. We’ve become a bit disconnected. And, I suspect that he’s been confiding too much in a female coworker who’s now encouraging him to divorce me. This breaks my heart. I just keep remembering the wonderful relationship that we used to have. And I know that this isn’t over for me. But, I don’t know what to do. If he wants a divorce, does this mean that it’s over and I just have to give him one? Is there anything that I can do to change his mind or to improve things?” There were many questions and issues brought up here. In the following article, I will try to address them.

Don’t Focus All Of Your Attention On What He’s Thinking. Focus On The Actions That  Take Instead: It’s not uncommon to see wives in this situation become almost obsessed with their husband’s thought process at this time. They want to know exactly what he’s thinking, why he is thinking this way, and what, exactly it’s going to take to change his mind. I know this because, when I was in this same situation, this is exactly what I did.

But, here’s the problem with that strategy. What man do you know that is willing (and much less able) to share his thought process with you? More than this, men often see right through this strategy and will either guard their thoughts like a crown jewel or resent that you even asked. Sometimes, they’ll even assume that you’re only trying to know what they are thinking so that you can argue with them, try to prove them wrong, or thwart their need to be truly happy.

This is probably not the stance you want to take, nor is it the situation that you want to find yourself in. And, the real risk that I find with focusing so much on his thoughts is that many times, this becomes your sole focus and then you dwell only upon the negative and the fear that it brings you. Often, his thoughts about the divorce become your thoughts and this whole thing becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.

What’s even worse than that, though, is allowing for the fears and the hyper focus on the negative to keep you from taking the action that might help you to fix some of the issues and to avoid the divorce ever moving forward in the first place.

What you often need (instead of trying or hoping to read his mind) is a plan to change his mind. You can’t read, demand, or control his thoughts. But, if you play your cards right, you might be able to influence them and give them a gentle nudge in the direction you want them to go. In my opinion and experience, this should be your focus on instead.

Encouraging Him To Change His Perceptions About A Divorce Without Making It Too Obvious: This wife was in a situation where she knew some of the issues that were clouding her husband’s perceptions. Therefore, she really did know where to start, even if she feared that she didn’t. To me, the best place to start was the disconnect that they were experiencing. And, debating with her husband or trying to show him where he was wrong was only going to make him feel more disconnected from her.

In my observation, the best strategy is often strategically placing your cards on the table.

Rather than dancing around or being negative about the issues, she could spin them and jump on his side. She could tell him that while it’s not a secret that his thinking about a divorce was extremely distressing to her, she absolutely agreed that the marriage needed some drastic improvements and that she too, was tired of not being as happy as they both should be. She should stress that she wants for them to be happy and for them to maintain positive interactions going forward since her relationship with him (in whatever form this took) was too important to act in a way that was going to deteriorate it.

Depending on the husband’s reaction, she could offer to give him some space. She could offer to stay with family or friends while he sorts things out. (This keeps him from leaving and from potentially not coming back or moving forward with the divorce.) If he did insist on leaving, she could ask that he commit to not file for divorce for a certain period of time. Whether he agreed to this or not, the plan should be the same – which should be to begin to change his perceptions about her and about the marriage.

Focus On The Things That Have Brought About Positive Perceptions In The Past: Always remember the things your husband found attractive and appealing about you in the past. The truth is that a scared, desperate, and overly emotional woman is not considered to be all that appealing to most men. Desperation brings about guilt feelings that they want to escape. Even if you don’t at all feel that you are, always try to appear positive, empathetic, confident, and that you are coping in a surprisingly positive way. Go out with friends or do whatever it takes to put a genuine smile on your face when you interact with him. Sometimes this newfound control will make him pause and he’ll want to dig a little deeper to see what brought about this change.

And this is usually going to be where your opportunity is. At some point in time, this husband and wife were going to need to address their financial and intimacy issues. However, the early stages were, in my opinion, not the time to do this. The husband was likely not going to be receptive until he began to feel connected to his wife again.

When my husband initiated a divorce, I did not understand these principles and I went about saving the marriage in the completely wrong way. I stooped to negative behavior that only drove my husband further away. Thankfully, I soon realized my mistake and decided to approach things from another angle and this eventually worked. You can read that story on my blog at https://isavedmymarriage.com/.

My Spouse Only Wants Contact By Phone During Our Trial Separation. How Do I Handle This?

By: Leslie Cane: Many separated wives find that their husband is trying to keep them at a far distance during their trial separation. The wife may have hoped that the separation would make things better. But when she finds her husband being resistant to her, it can cause her to wonder if her marriage even stands a chance.

A comment that I might hear in this situation is an example like: “I’m not the one who wanted the separation. My husband was. I resisted for a long time. But eventually, he made it pretty clear that if I didn’t agree to the separation, he’d have no choice but to pursue a divorce. So I reluctantly agreed, but only after he assured me that he would stay in close contact and that we would still see each other and keep in regular face to face communication. Well, part of this is true. He does call me regularly. But every time I mention coming by or the two of us getting together, my husband balks at this. He says that he needs more time and that he is not ready for that yet. Part of me is considering just showing up at his apartment and hoping that he will let me in, but another part of me is afraid that he’s discouraging the face to face contact because he is seeing someone else. I’m grateful to be communicating by phone, but I need more than this. How can I get him to see me face to face? I want personal contact. He’s my husband. I shouldn’t have to communicate with him by phone only.”

I agree with this wife that the phone contact isn’t the ideal. And I absolutely understand why she wanted and needed more. But I also know, by my own experience, that sometimes you have to settle for what you can easily obtain while you are setting the groundwork to obtain more. Because if you push too hard too soon, you might put yourself in a situation where your husband starts to taper off (or even end) the phone contact. That is the last thing that you want. Once he stops the phone contact, you might have an extremely difficult time re-establishing any contact at all without appearing too desperate.

Try Building Upon What You Already Have First: I know that this may not be what you want to hear, but it’s my opinion and experience that you are often better off gradually building upon what you already have. What I mean by this is that the best idea, at least in my opinion, is to continue on with the phone conversations with enough enthusiasm that they become more and more frequent and more and more pleasurable for both of you. Because if you can set it up to where you’re both laughing and looking forward to your phone conversations, then the next logical step would be to meet. And in this way, you haven’t applied any pressure. You haven’t laid on any guilt. And your husband has very willingly and very naturally moved forward.

This is so much better than just showing up at his apartment one day and being rejected or risking him pulling back from you. It’s best if he is a willing participant in every bit of the process. You don’t want to force anything on him and face rejection.

The “Coincidental” Meeting Strategy: Another option would be to run into him at a time where you know where he is going to be and to make it look like a coincidence. However, because this strategy runs a high risk of not actually being believable, I believe that it should be a last resort. I believe it’s best to try to build on the phone conversations in a very natural way before you resort to the “accidental meeting” strategy. Many husbands will see right through this. They will doubt that you just happened to be at the same place at the same time. And as a result, they may start to avoid you.

I know that you want more than phone conversations. But know that if you play this correctly and you move gradually, this phase of your separation won’t last forever. As you resist applying pressure and as things continue to improve between you, then it’s probable that he will just naturally want to see you face to face after a little while.

Unfortunately, in my own situation I didn’t follow this advice.  I took to just showing up places and this infuriated my husband so much that it almost caused a divorce.  I had to do about complete about-face and regroup in order to save my marriage. If it helps, you can read more on my blog at https://isavedmymarriage.com

I Can’t Even Fathom Getting A Divorce. But My Husband Wants One

By: Leslie Cane: Many of the wives that read my articles are opposed to a divorce. Usually, their husbands are the ones pushing to end the marriage while they’re trying to do everything in their power to save it. For many wives, a divorce is the absolute worst-case scenario.

A wife might say: “To me, divorce is a failure. It’s giving up when you don’t have to. It’s throwing your family away without trying everything in your power to make things right. To me, marriage is forever and divorce isn’t an option. Unfortunately, my husband doesn’t feel the same way. He’s ready to just walk away and it’s not fair. He knows how opposed I am to divorcing, and yet he’s moving forward anyway. And now I feel like I have no choice but to allow him to end our marriage even though it’s not over for me. What can I do?”

I very much understand how this wife feels because I was in the same situation. You can feel very isolated and lonely. Because, at the end of the day, it’s nearly impossible to “make” or “get” someone to save the marriage without there being a good deal of resentment that’s going to ruin the relationship anyway. But yes, divorce was the one thing I didn’t want to happen. And, I felt that if I let it happen, it was going to be my life’s biggest failure. It absolutely broke my heart to think that my husband might be moving on with his life without me. I floored me to think that there might be a time when we weren’t a couple and that I would not have him in my life anymore.

But here’s the rub. The more you get caught up in opposing the divorce, typically the more your husband wants it. The whole thing becomes a relationship catch 22 because it forces you to cling more tightly than what might be comfortable or typical for you. Few husbands react well to these kinds of amplified emotions that are directed exactly toward them. In the following article, I’ll discuss some ways to find common ground when he wants the divorce that you simply can’t bear the thought of.

Define Those Things About The Divorce That Are The Most Objectionable And Painful To You: Sometimes, when you’re dealing with a very vague enemy, it’s quite hard to make things better because you don’t have specific issues to address. Merely saying that you can’t bear the thought of being divorced doesn’t really tell us all that much. It helps if you can make a list of those things that are most upsetting to you and then try to tackle those in a methodical way.

For example, most people in this situation are operating under the guise of fear and don’t much like treading on this new territory. Some common things that you’re grieving are often the loss of a family, the loss of the relationship with your husband, and the change of your lifestyle and the people in it. It really can help to try to work through these issues individually. Because if you can do this, you’re behaviors and your interactions with your husband will often change for the better (at least in his eyes) and this makes it easier for you to open up a new batch of opportunities.

If losing the relationship scares you, then approach your husband about trying to maintain it, even if the definition of it changes. (And it may only change temporarily. But re-defining it gives you a place to start.) In other words, whatever the fears are underneath the larger objection to the divorce, try to break them down and deal with them in a smaller way, rather than trying to combat a huge and vague fear which just seems too overwhelming anyway.

Understand That Sometimes, Stalling, Avoiding, Or Stopping The Divorce Means Not Fighting Against It In Negative Ways: Honestly, I believe that most women who tell me that a divorce is their worst case scenario are focusing on ways to stop the divorce rather than on ways to cope and adjust to it. This is completely understandable and I did the exact same thing. But, it’s so important to understand that if you’re reacting badly and focusing on the negative in order to guilt, shame, or beg your husband into reconsidering the divorce, you’re likely making the very thing that you fear the most that much more likely.

A husband’s wanting a divorce is most likely his reaction to being somewhat unhappy in the relationship and then thinking that nothing about that same relationship is going to change. So in order to change his mind about it, he has to see that he can feel positive emotions that stem from your relationship again. And, this in turn shows him that he was wrong in his assumptions that nothing was ever going to change.

I know it might sound as though I’m suggesting a very risky proposition. But, stalling, stopping, or delaying a divorce has so much more to do with the strategy of throwing negative emotions at the problem. Your husband is likely expecting you to act or react in a very predictable way. For this reason, he’s likely bracing himself to tune you out, to ignore you, or to just say things to pacify you with no real intention of following up.

If you want to change the way that he sees you and the marriage, you must change your message. It might be a decent idea to stop stressing how the divorce is the worst, most heartbreaking idea that you ever heard and then change your focus onto just rehabilitating the relationship. Stress that you can’t change his mind or alter his feelings, but because he’s so important to you, it’s vital that you can maintain a positive relationship. By doing this, you’re trying to ensure that one of your worst fears doesn’t actually come true, and you’ve likely gained yourself more access to him during which time you can try to change those perceptions that are driving him toward the divorce.

It was my husband (and not me) who was pushing for the divorce. My behaviors were based on fear and did nothing to help my cause. Thankfully, I realized my strategy wasn’t working and changed my thinking. I used some of the tactics that I discussed here (sloppily at first) and they eventually worked. You can read more on my blog at https://isavedmymarriage.com/

 

My Separated Husband Says I Don’t Understand Him

By: Leslie Cane: When you are separated but don’t want to be, you’re often looking for any opportunity to feel closer to your separated husband. One way you might try to do this is to get him to talk to you and share his feelings. You figure if you can continue to communicate, then at least you have a chance to build upon that and eventually reconnect.

But what happens if he doesn’t want to communicate with you due to an allegation that you believe is untrue? Namely, that you wouldn’t understand anyway or that you don’t understand him at all.

A wife might say, “I am desperately trying to maintain a feeling of closeness with my separated husband. I try to communicate with him once every day since he is the one who wanted more time away from me. There have been times when he willingly takes my calls, but lately, he seems much more reluctant to talk to me. I can’t bring myself to give up because if I do, I could see us drifting apart and getting to the point of no return. So yesterday, when it was like pulling teeth to get my husband to talk to me, I asked him why it seemed so painful for him to converse. His response was that it was a waste of time because I don’t understand him anyway, and I most definitely do not understand his life right now – so I can in no way have a meaningful conversation with him.”  

“This is hogwash. I’ve known him for many years. We have shared a life together. I know his deepest fears and his most prevalent wishes. I tried to explain this to him, but he won’t hear it and merely says that our lives are different now and I don’t understand him in our new lives. Again, this is all hogwash, but he won’t listen to me. How can I manage this? I do not want to back off on communications with him, but it is hard to have a real conversation if he will not open up because he thinks I don’t understand him.”

Why You Might Be Seeing This Behavior: I completely get your concern. I often encourage separated wives to do every reasonable thing to maintain communication. However, there is a caveat with that. Sometimes, if your communication is actually damaging the relationship or making things more awkward or tense, then it sometimes makes sense to at least reevaluate how you are communicating. There are some common reasons that a separated husband will think you don’t understand him, as well as some reasons that he might back away from communication. I will discuss these things below. 

Why a Separated Husband Might Think You “Don’t Understand” Him:  Whether your husband wants to admit it or not, both of your emotional lives have likely changed dramatically. And that type of swing might leave you struggling in various ways even if you think you are coping or are happy. 

Granted, the things he is juggling or dealing with may well be different than the things with which you are juggling. His feelings may be quite a bit different than yours since he willingly wanted this separation. And that may well be what he means when he tells you you do not understand.  

He is looking at it from the perspective of someone who willingly took this on, and you are not. He may also think that no person can feel what someone else is feeling or having the same thoughts. He may think that he can’t adequately explain these things, so it’s easier to just proclaim you don’t understand. 

Still, that doesn’t mean that you aren’t struggling with the same issues of uncertainty – even if he doesn’t realize it. And it doesn’t mean that you wouldn’t try your best to put yourself in his shoes.

And while you may understand all of this and want him to understand it too, he might not be at the place where he is willing to – at least just yet.

Why a Separated Husband Might Back Away From Communication and Use the “Understanding” as a Reason:  Many separated husbands will balk at constant communication – especially when they were the ones who initiated the separation. They suspect that your reason for wanting to communicate so often is to determine what they are feeling and therefore what they might want.

They often don’t have a quick answer for you. In the same way that you are, they’re trying to feel their way and get used to this new normal. Like you, they’ve not been separated before, and they may not be sure how they feel – but they know that you want to know – and are using the communication to try to figure it out.

Therefore, they might keep you at arm’s length to avoid that kind of scrutiny and pressure. I’m not saying it is wrong of you to want to know what your husband is thinking. I most definitely felt that during my own separation. But I am trying to explain why you might be seeing the behavior that you are.

A Way to Proceed That Won’t Cause More Harm:  I know firsthand that it’s tempting to try to communicate even more to goad him into talking frankly with you. I did that. It was a mistake. It backfired. After I did it, my husband communicated with me even less than before and was less happy to hear from me when I did manage to get him on the phone.

Instead of making the mistakes I did, you want to learn how to gauge your husband’s response to you and proceed accordingly. I know that it is difficult to be this brutally honest with yourself, but it can help tremendously. When your husband is standoffish, tells you that you don’t understand, or just isn’t receptive, you might tell him that you’re trying your very best to support him, and then give it a few days to calm down.

Don’t keep going back at him if he’s made it clear he isn’t receptive. Give him time to notice your absence, and he might see things a bit differently in short order. 

I know that I’m asking you to do the very thing you fear – to tone down communication for just a bit – but I know from experience that pushing can get you the opposite of what you want. And it can make the separation longer and more awkward. You can read about how I eventually turned things around during my own separation and reconciled at https://isavedmymarriage.com

I Suspect My Disgruntled Husband Wants Me to Leave. That’s the Last Thing I Want

By: Leslie Cane: It’s an awful feeling when you know that a marital separation might be on the horizon. It’s an even worse feeling when you suspect that your spouse is strongly hinting that you should be the one to leave. Often, this is your home and where you feel the most comfortable. And, assuming that you are still invested in your marriage, you can intuitively know that once you leave, it may be difficult to find a way back.

Someone might explain: “my husband is not being at all shy about telling me that he is pretty sure that he wants a separation. He is very fond of telling me how very unhappy he is. Last night, he said that I had to know that we were headed for a separation and he stated that when this happens, he is pretty sure that I am the one who should move out. My husband was renting our house when I met him. However, when we got married, we bought the house together. So I can see how he thinks that this was his house for longer than it was mine, but I have been making joint payments on it for years. More than that, though, it’s my home and I do not want to leave. I also do not want to walk out on my marriage. I am not even thinking mostly about finances right now. I am thinking that if I leave, I might end up divorced and that is definitely not what I want.”

“I can’t point to any big problem that we have. It’s just that we have grown apart and we seem to annoy one another and then fight over stupid things. But no one committed any deal breakers or anything. So I just do not understand why I can not at least try to work it out. It seems very premature to just assume that I’m going to willingly leave my home. He’s heavily hinting that I should leave, but I certainly don’t want to. The mortgage is in both of our names. And I really don’t want to leave the only home that I’ve known for years.”

Why Moving Out May Feel Premature: I don’t blame you. I’m not an attorney and would not dream of giving legal advice. But from a relationship standpoint, I would think that it would be in your best interest to stay put, if at all possible. I know that in some cases, this is not feasible as the situation has become toxic or even dangerous, but that does not seem to be the case here. It simply sounds as if you and your husband are not clicking in the way that you used to, so your husband is starting to think that it would make the most sense to live apart.

I think that the word that you’re already used which best describes the situation is “premature.” If you haven’t yet tried giving your husband space while the two of you still live together, or you haven’t tried counseling (or at least talking about what needs to happen in order to improve things,) then I would agree with you that it’s very premature.

In my own observations, once someone moves out, it’s more difficult to reconcile simply because you no longer have the proximity to one another. Your spouse can avoid you if he wants and then you’re left to make unfortunate and worrisome assumptions, which can only increase the distance and awkwardness between you. That’s not to say that you can’t reconcile after living apart. I did it, but I believe that it was made more difficult by the living arrangements.

Having a Candid Conversation: I don’t think that it would hurt to share your hesitation with your husband. That’s certainly a better option than just moving out and praying that you will one day be able to move back in, with no guarantees. I would try something like: “I don’t necessarily agree that we need to be headed toward a separation or even living separately. I understand that things aren’t great, but we haven’t even tried to work it out. There are many things that could be tried before we make the very drastic and life-altering decision to break up our marriage. Speaking of life-altering, I also don’t agree with just picking up and leaving my home. If you think that we need space from one another, then I certainly believe that this could be accomplished by occupying different parts of the house for a while. I do not like the idea of just leaving before we’ve even tried to make things right. I am willing to do whatever is necessary to make things good again. I believe that this is possible. And I definitely don’t believe that just throwing up our hands and one of us packing our bags is the right solution. That sounds very premature to me. Why don’t we brainstorm some things to try first?”

Then, listen to what he has to say. He may have just been testing you when he suggested that you move out. Perhaps he will be receptive to trying to improve things before you move toward a separation. I can tell you first hand that a separation is very difficult emotionally. (You can read about mine at https://isavedmymarriage.com) If you can avoid it, that would certainly be best. You can certainly save your marriage if you separate, but why go through that if you don’t have to?